Christianity is a great moral system for internal use – not so much for external relations.
Being soft and benevolent works beautifully inside a society where everyone plays by the same code: it produces the most trusting, generous and peaceful communities in history. Applied indiscriminately to those who play by different rules, it becomes a self-defeating strategy. That is not cynicism. It is game theory: unconditional cooperation feeds the cheaters, and cooperation survives only when it can recognize cheating and answer it.
Other, more predatory civilizations are simply being rational within their own moral approach, which is a bit different from ours. They respect strength and read softness as weakness. Then they resent us for being both richer and weaker – and they act on it.
The Church knew this once. Augustine and Aquinas did not preach a defenseless Christendom; they wrote the doctrine of just war.
If we want to keep our nice, soft, benevolent societies internally – and we do – then we need to learn a bit from the others, especially in external relations. Kindness inside requires firmness at the border.
A soft interior needs a hard shell. That is not a betrayal of Christian civilization. It is the only way it survives.
https://x.com/Kristof_Poland/status/2122595003620847631?a=ekS_0s_0PZoXD_cuwZk&s=20
What Is Christianity at Its Deepest?
It is the reflex of caring about every other person: their suffering hurts you, and you want to help.
That is what we call the dignity of every human being – even our enemies. This is a revolutionary idea. Christ put it in three words: love your enemies.
Sometimes we even overdo it. At home, I am laughed at because I try to rescue every fruit fly I see in trouble – which is indeed excessive :)
But what we have to understand is that this is not the natural default setting of the ruthless, territorial, tribal killer apes that we are. And so not every civilization shares this reflex. We acquire it very young, as little children, as the normal way to behave – and then we project it onto everyone else, assuming that all others work the same way. They do not. It is not the human default. It is Christianity.
The human default is the opposite: to rejoice at the misery and suffering of others – of enemies, of members of other tribes. Or at least indifference. It is quite understandable: it is the natural instinct of predator societies. And it was ours too. In Rome, we filled the Colosseum to watch men kill each other, and we lived off slaves. The opposite had to be learned – it is civilizational – and it took millennia. Tradition says the gladiator games ended when a monk jumped into the arena to separate two fighters, and the crowd killed him for it. The crowd was nature. The monk was Christianity.
Even Nietzsche, Christianity's fiercest enemy, understood this better than many believers. He saw that compassion for the weak was not nature but Christian morality – and attacked it for this very reason. Indeed, taken too far, it is a mistake – it becomes suicidal. We have to restore measure to it. Augustine put it best, teaching that we owe love to all, but since we cannot help everyone, we must first help those whom time and place have brought closest to us – what the Church calls the order of charity.
And this is how different civilizations still operate. Moral obligation stops at the edge of the family, the clan, the tribe; beyond it, people instinctively care only about their own interest – at the expense of others, to varying degrees. Anthropologists who measure it find the West to be the exception, not the rule. We have to understand that, and not project our moral code onto them – that is a mistake. Sometimes a very costly mistake for those who do not understand it.
This is what distinguishes civilizations at the deepest level. We should be conscious of what we are, and where it comes from.
Incidentally, this is what makes envy-based systems like communism a different civilization. Compassion suffers at the suffering of others. Envy suffers at their happiness – and rejoices at their fall. Communism turned that reflex into a system: the class enemy, the show trial, the cheering crowd. It brought back the arena. Today's online mob is the same arena, with likes instead of thumbs.
At the opposite end stands the famous motto of the Polish fighters, who fought for the freedom of others:
For Our Freedom and Yours.

No comments:
Post a Comment