Translated from French
Martin Luther urged the German princes to mercilessly slaughter the rebellious peasants and drew up a program of ethnic cleansing calling for all synagogues and Jewish homes to be burned.
Yet he remains celebrated around the world as the father of the Protestant Reformation in the 16th century. The courageous monk who defied the Vatican’s corruption and translated the Bible into German is honored.
In the collective imagination, the theologian of Wittenberg remains the great liberator of individual conscience. He embodies the founder of modern Christianity in opposition to the dogmatism of the Roman Church.
The reality is established by his own pamphlets in the Weimar critical edition and by the work of historian Thomas Kaufmann. It reveals a preacher whose fanatical violence was directed against the poorest and the Jews.
In 1524 and 1525, hundreds of thousands of starving German peasants rise up. They refuse serfdom and the crushing taxes imposed by the lords. They draw inspiration from the ideas of Christian freedom preached by Luther.
But the reformer immediately sides with the princes who protect him. In May 1525, he publishes a fiery tract entitled Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants.
In this text, he orders the lords to crush the revolt in blood. Anyone who can must strike down, slaughter, and stab the peasants in secret or in public. They must be killed exactly as one puts down a rabid dog.
He even promises paradise to soldiers who die massacring these serfs. The princes’ repression leaves nearly 100,000 dead among the defeated peasants. Luther then proudly claims that all their blood is on his neck.
Toward the end of his life, his fury turns against the Jews who refuse to convert. In 1543, he publishes his treatise On the Jews and Their Lies.
This 65,000-word book is a veritable manual of persecution in 7 points. It is addressed directly to the German political authorities.
Luther demands that all synagogues and Jewish schools be burned down. He orders their homes to be razed and the Jews to be confined in stables like Bohemians.
He also calls for their prayer books to be confiscated and for rabbis to be forbidden to teach on pain of death. He asks that all their money and jewelry be seized. Young Jews must be put to forced labor before being expelled from the country.
The man whom history honors as the champion of spiritual freedom thus blessed the massacre of 100,000 peasants. He also theorized the methodical destruction of Germany’s Jewish communities.
https://x.com/AugusteBardamu/status/2121879589978779944?a=pTiMWPsFDB-cW6WyIfc&s=20
My ancestors were Calvinists persecuted in France and expelled ; not Lutheran.
LUTHER estabished LUTHERANISM not Protestant religion.
The 16th-century Reformation: different figures and theological traditions played foundational roles.
• Jan Hus: A Czech theologian and philosopher born in the 14th century (c. 1369–1415) who preceded Martin Luther by over a century. Hus criticized clerical corruption, the sale of indulgences, and papal authority, and he is widely regarded as a key precursor to the Protestant Reformation who was burned at the stake for his views.
( my Ancestors Kutzer , Hildebrandt)
• Huldrych Zwingli: A leader of the Reformation in German-speaking Switzerland (1484–1531) who independently developed a reform theology parallel to Luther's, emphasizing the supreme authority of scripture while differing notably from Luther on the nature of the Eucharist and sacraments.
(My ancestors Yzelle(
• John Calvin: The French theologian (1509–1564) whose systematic theology and leadership in Geneva shaped the Reformed and Presbyterian traditions, which many later Protestants viewed as developing a more thoroughly distinct path from medieval Catholicism than Luther's own conservative retention of certain sacramental practices.
( 204 French Huguenots - my ancestors )
Martin Luther: The contradiction between Christian freedom and religious intolerance.
There is something deeply contradictory about how Martin Luther is celebrated as the great liberator of individual conscience, while so much of his own writing reveals an extraordinarily authoritarian, judgemental, and intolerant disposition.
His response to the German Peasants' War in 1524–25 is particularly revealing. Many of the peasants were motivated by demands for justice, freedom from oppressive feudal obligations and a Christian understanding of human dignity.
Yet Luther, who had initially helped create an atmosphere of religious challenge to established authority, turned decisively against them. In 'Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants' (1525), he urged the princes to slaughter the rebels without mercy. His later antisemitic tract, 'On the Jews and Their Lies' (1543), advocated burning synagogues, destroying Jewish homes, confiscating property and suppressing Jewish religious teaching.
These were not minor inconsistencies. They expose a profound problem in Luther's understanding of Christian liberty. He challenged the authority of Rome but appeared quite prepared to endorse the coercive authority of German princes when it suited his religious and political position.
I would go further, however, and question the philosophical and theological foundations of his rebellion.
Luther's attack on indulgences needs to be understood in its historical context. There were genuine abuses in the way indulgences were promoted and monetised. But that was different from the merciless exploitation of the princes that Luther so readily excused.
The Church's relationship with money and the financing of religious institutions deserved scrutiny. The Catholic Church was not frozen in dogma but quite the opposite.
The money financed the Renaissance, and the great changes it funded are often overlooked. The Church was granting greater freedoms, and Luther filled that space with his ideas. Like Mao, he abused the freedoms to overthrow an institution that was evolving.
Protestants have deliberately misrepresented the Roman Church. This is the negative projection of the other and the heart of Protestantism.
One might draw an analogy with the way modern governments impose financial penalties or taxes on particular behaviours: the existence of an institutional mechanism does not, in itself, invalidate the underlying moral or philosophical principle. The abuses of indulgence preaching should not automatically be confused with the entire theological understanding of penance, forgiveness, temporal consequences and reconciliation that had developed within Catholic theology.
More fundamentally, Luther narrowed the question of redemption around *sola fide* — justification by faith alone. It is important to acknowledge that he did not simply advocate abandoning good works. He regarded them as the natural fruits of genuine faith. But he fundamentally altered their theological significance.
The Catholic tradition, particularly through St Thomas Aquinas, offers a more integrated understanding of the relationship between faith, grace, human nature, virtue and good works. Human beings are not simply passive objects awaiting a declaration of justification. They are moral beings, capable of participating in the life of grace, developing virtue, exercising responsibility and being transformed through their relationship with God.
This brings us to a much deeper philosophical distinction.
Aquinas understood existence, or being, through a profound metaphysical framework. God is not simply an object within the universe, nor one explanatory force alongside other forces. God is the ground of being itself — ipsum esse subsistens, subsistent being itself. The mystery of God therefore transcends the categories through which human beings attempt to understand existence.
I worry that aspects of Luther's theology reduce this profound mystery to a much narrower argument about the mechanics of salvation, faith, divine judgement and human sin. His treatment of providence, the human will and the relationship between God and humanity raises difficult questions about time, eternity, freedom and moral responsibility.
There is a danger here of turning God into an object of theological argument, rather than recognising the transcendent mystery from which all existence derives.
I also find Luther's psychological and moral disposition troubling. Rather than consistently confronting the complexity of sin within human nature, he repeatedly directed his polemics against external enemies: Rome, the peasants, the Jews and those who disagreed with him. There is an uncomfortable sense of projection here. The sinner becomes identified with the opposing group, rather than the universal human condition that Christianity asks us to confront within ourselves.
His writing frequently displays a punitive and judgemental understanding of other people. It is difficult not to see in this a dark strain of Puritanism, subsequently developed in different ways within Protestant traditions, and particularly in some interpretations of Calvinist theology.
Christianity, however, should surely be about humility, self-examination, compassion and the recognition that every human being stands in need of grace.
The Catholic intellectual tradition was not simply an oppressive structure of dogma waiting to be liberated by Luther. It represented centuries of philosophical development, debate and theological refinement, from Augustine to Aquinas and beyond. Its understanding of ontology, natural law, virtue, reason, grace and the mystery of existence is considerably more sophisticated than the caricature of medieval Catholicism that has sometimes become embedded in the popular account of the Reformation.
None of this denies the corruption and abuses within the medieval Church. Reform was happening. But reform and intellectual destruction are not the same thing.
Luther deserves recognition for his historical influence, his contribution to biblical translation and his challenge to ecclesiastical abuses. But historical influence should not be confused with moral greatness, and religious rebellion should not automatically be equated with spiritual enlightenment.
Perhaps the greatest irony is that a man celebrated for liberating Christian conscience could be so merciless in judging the consciences of others.
The Christian challenge is not simply to identify the sinner outside ourselves, but to understand the nature of sin within ourselves. That is a considerably more d

No comments:
Post a Comment